A Second Chance for the Botched Election of 26 September 2021? What Would the Process Look Like?
Background
The last elections to the German Bundestag and the Berlin House of Representatives were anything but smooth in the capital. The reasons included incorrect or missing voter registers, too few poll workers, the temporary closure of polling stations and generally long waiting times before voting, assuming people even made it there despite the road closures for the Berlin Marathon on the same day. Given these poor conditions, politicians and the public are now discussing new elections. But what does that actually mean? And how would we get there?
Are all new elections the same?
The Federal Elections Act (BWG) distinguishes between a new election (Neuwahl), a supplementary election (Nachwahl) and a repeat election (Wiederholungswahl). A new election follows the early end of a legislative term, that is, the dissolution of the Bundestag by the Federal President. The Basic Law (GG) provides for this in two cases: when the Federal Chancellor is not elected by an absolute majority of MPs (Article 63(4) GG), or when the Chancellor’s motion for a vote of confidence does not get the support of a majority of Bundestag members (Article 68 GG). If the Bundestag is dissolved, a new election must take place within sixty days (BWG Section 39(2)). After a new election, the new Bundestag meets within thirty days at the latest (BWG Section 39(2)). Under the BWG, a new election is the same as a “normal” federal election, just with shorter deadlines. Eligible voters must therefore be entered in the voter registers as for a regular election. Postal votes must also be requested again.
A supplementary election only takes place if the election could not be held in a constituency or polling district, or if a constituency candidate dies after their nomination was approved but before the election, as happened in Dresden in 2005 (BWG Section 43(1)). In the first case, the supplementary election must take place no later than three weeks after the main election; in the second case, no later than six weeks.
A new or supplementary election can therefore be ruled out as a consequence of Berlin’s chaotic election of 26 September 2021. However, a repeat election can be ordered. This happens when the election is declared wholly or partly invalid in an election review procedure (BWG Section 44(1)). For this, the Committee for the Scrutiny of Elections must make a corresponding recommendation, which the Bundestag plenary must then adopt.
The path to a repeat election
On 8 September 2022, the Bundestag’s Committee for the Scrutiny of Elections discussed its recommendation on the Federal Returning Officer’s objection and on the election in Berlin. The specific results of these discussions have not yet been made public. The plenary vote on the recommendation is now expected this month (October), in order to wait for the Berlin Constitutional Court’s deliberations on a possible repeat of the Berlin state election.
On 28 September, Berlin’s highest court concluded in a preliminary assessment that the electoral errors were relevant to the allocation of seats, meaning they affected the composition of parliament and the distribution of seats. Only a complete repeat election could restore a constitutional state of affairs. This assessment by the Berlin Constitutional Court now also affects the legal assessment of the federal election. The decision on repeating the Bundestag election was originally due to be made in the Committee for the Scrutiny of Elections on Thursday, 29 September, but has now been postponed in response to the Berlin Constitutional Court’s statement.
Features of a repeat election
If less than six months have passed since the main election when the election review decision is made, the election is repeated under the same rules, with the same nominations and voter registers (BWG Section 44(2)). If the election is repeated only in individual polling districts within these six months, eligible voters can take part if they used their postal voting certificate from the main election in the districts where the election is being repeated. People who have since moved out of the area of the repeat election can, on request, get their voting certificate back with a note that it is valid for the repeat election (Federal Electoral Regulations (BWO) Section 83(4) and (5)). Since more than six months have now passed since the main election, the election review decision may lead to changes in how the election is organized and carried out. However, if the repeat election only takes place in individual polling districts, their boundaries may not be changed (BWO Section 83(2)). Nominations can only be changed if this follows from the election review decision or if a candidate has died or is no longer eligible.
Voting certificates may only be issued by municipalities in the area where the repeat election takes place. Voters who have lost their right to vote since the main election must be removed from the voter register.
The repeat election must take place no later than sixty days after the decision declaring the main election invalid becomes final (BWG Section 44(3)). Assuming the plenary adopts a decision for a repeat election in one of the two sitting weeks in October (calendar weeks 41 or 42), the repeat election would have to take place in mid-December this year under the Federal Elections Act and the Federal Electoral Regulations.
The exact date of the repeat election is set by the State Returning Officer. On 1 October 2022, political and administrative scientist Stephan Bröchler took over this role. He was elected by the Berlin Senate on 6 September 2022 and replaces Ulrike Rockmann, who had already said at the start of the year that she wanted to step down from the honorary position.
What follows from the process
So what would a potential repeat of the Bundestag election in Berlin mean?
According to media reports, a partial repeat vote in 440 of Berlin’s 2,257 polling stations is under discussion for the federal election. All twelve districts would be affected, especially Pankow, Mitte and Reinickendorf. However, the repeat election would probably be limited to the second vote (party vote), except in Reinickendorf. There, Monika Grütters won by only 1,788 votes against SPD candidate Torsten Einstmann. This is therefore the only constituency seat that could be at risk.
A repeat of the Bundestag election as currently discussed, limited to Berlin and to individual polling stations, would hardly affect the balance of power in the Bundestag, as the shift in second votes is unlikely to be large. In the last federal election, just under 1.85 million Berliners voted. About 20 percent of them, around 370,000 people, would vote again. That is only 0.8 percent of everyone who voted in the 2021 federal election.
However, the repeat election could have very concrete consequences for individual MPs. A shift in second votes could mean the end of the term for some MPs who were elected via their parties’ state lists. The latest polls already show a change in mood since the last election: the Greens and the CDU/CSU are gaining support at the expense of the SPD and the FDP. Which MPs would have to fear for their seats can only be estimated precisely once the Committee for the Scrutiny of Elections has set the scope of the repeat election.

